"A Price on the Sacred: When Religion Mobilizes and Restrains"
Abstract
How does religious observance affect political violence and protests? I argue that heightened observance raises the return to political actions that an actor’s doctrine can frame as worship, while raising the opportunity cost of actions that compete with worship for time. I test this using Ramadan, which rotates through the solar year. In predominantly Muslim states, armed conflict rises by about 4% during Ramadan, driven by religious insurgencies. Hourly military data from Afghanistan show that close combat rises nearly 9% and shifts toward periods after meals, consistent with fasting shaping the schedule of operations. A text analysis of a decade of weekly insurgent newsletters shows that their messaging turns substantially more devotional during the month, tying worship to combat. On the civilian side, protests fall by nearly 7%, and Muslims surveyed during Ramadan pray more and report less political interest and willingness to protest, with no comparable changes detected among non-Muslims. State-scripted religious messaging turns more devotional but no more political. The same shock mobilizes religious militants, for whom combat is worship, and restrains citizens, for whom protest competes with prayer.